Ashtray (First and Second)

Ok, So this one was no biggie, except the part where I lost 30min of my life trying to balance a ashtray on 3 bullets, conclusion, we need one more bullet, anyhow here are some reference pictures I used: 

And the second ashtray:

Alright, here are my models, and first off, the issues I had,

So like I mentioned, trying to balance the bullets for the first ashtray was a bit tricky so I had to introduce the forth bullet, here's the pic of the balance I managed to achieve:

And from different perspectives:

And second ashtray, I just reused the main mesh from the first one: